Dive into the exhibition Sicily: Art and Invention between Greece and Rome this week on Getty Voices, as curators Claire Lyons and Alexandra Sofroniew share thoughts on mysteries of a star sculpture of the exhibition and their favorite sites, stories, and tastes of Sicily. More from Claire and Alex all week: Getty Voices on Twitter | Getty Voices on FacebookIf only this ancient statue could speak...we could ask him who he is, and how he ended up on the tiny island of Mozia, just off the western coast of Sicily. The first work of art that most visitors to our exhibition Sicily: Art and Invention between Greece and Rome will encounter, this over-life-size marble youth may be the finest work of Greek sculpture surviving from antiquity. Transfixing you with a self-confident gaze, the figure proudly flaunts a muscular physique, a single fragmentary hand pressing the soft flesh of the hip. The incredible skill of the stone-carver is evident in the delicate pleats of the gossamer gown that clings sensuously to the body beneath, revealing much more than it conceals. Mozia (called Motya in ancient times) was a Carthaginian base, a stepping stone for the North African settlers who inhabited western Sicily. Nowadays, the whole island of Mozia is an archaeological site, preserving the remnants of a flourishing trading post that acted as a cultural crossroads between the Carthaginians, Greeks, and native Sicilian peoples. We still vividly remember our first visits out to Mozia, gingerly stepping into a small boat for the short crossing past tile-covered pyramids of salt and windmills to the shores of the island. Thousands of years before, the statue must have made a similar passage to Mozia, still only accessible by sea, but from where...Selinous, Akragas, Himera? Unearthed in 1979 during excavations of the area between a sanctuary and a potter’s workshop, lying on his back in a pile of rubble, the so-called Mozia Charioteer has been the subject of ongoing debate. Was he carved by a Greek sculptor, or a Sicilian Greek artist? How did he end up on Mozia? And most of all, who is he? The fiercest discussion has centered on his identification: is he a hero or a god, a victorious athlete or a ruling tyrant from one of the Sicilian metropolises? This April, a distinguished group of scholars from Sicily, other parts of Italy, and the U.S. gathered at the Getty Villa to address these questions. In the weeks before, rumors had been swirling that our speakers would propose some new theories. Classical art is millennia old, but there is still much to study, learn—and debate. Our study day, “Rethinking the Mozia Youth,” began in the seminar rooms at the Villa, where we have scholarly convenings. Clemente Marconi, a professor at the New York University Institute of Fine Arts, argued for the traditional interpretation of the youth as a victorious charioteer. As evidence, he pointed to the great number of Sicilian Greek coins showing a charioteer wearing similar garb of long belted garment, with a victor’s wreath on his head. Caterina Greco, director of the Archaeological Park of Selinunte, agreed that the youth was a charioteer, but proposed that instead of a local athlete, the statue portrays the mythical Pelops, admired for his great beauty and prowess as a charioteer. And the dissenting opinion? UCLA professor John Papadopoulos offered a radical rethinking, arguing that he is a dancer, performing a sacred ceremony in honor of Apollo Karneios and raising his arm to support a large basket on his head. He based this argument on the presence of fully five ancient holes drilled in the statue's head, which suggest that it was once adorned with something larger and heavier than a helmet or meniskos (protective disk). John made his case by showing this detail of a Greek vase—arguing that the youth might once have worn a headdress as dramatic as the figure at center (called out in red), with a pose like the figure at the far right (in blue). Put the basket of the red figure on the pose of the blue one, "and you've got the Motya Youth." Jerry Podany, the Getty’s senior conservator of antiquities, followed, discussing the mount that he engineered to protect the statue from earthquake damage—as great a risk in western Sicily as here in Los Angeles. Liberated for the first time from its previous support system, the Mozia Youth and can be fully appreciated as he was meant to be, from all sides. Intense conversation continued in the galleries, in the presence of the statue itself. Here professor Andrew Stewart from the University of California at Berkeley pointed out that the sculptor would have required a huge block of marble to carve the piece, demonstrating the expense and effort required to bring the stone from the Greek island of Paros, where the stone was quarried, to Sicily. The conclusion? We agreed to disagree, and that research should continue. But while the true identity of the Mozia Youth may be lost in the mists of time, he is unquestionably one of the world’s world’s most breathtaking ancient sculptures. As co-curators of the exhibition, we have both been thinking about the Mozia Charioteer for more than three years, when we began planning the exhibition. Our love affairs with Sicily began much earlier, however. We both first encountered Sicily as students, spending the summers on archaeological excavations. These glorious long weeks afforded time to explore the island. With our groups of keen archaeologists, we visited sites and museums in the sizzling heat, occasionally washing the dust off alongside holiday-makers on the bustling beaches. Today, we feel enormously lucky and proud to have the Mozia Charioteer here with us in Malibu until August 19. Take the boat trip to Mozia another time (it's well worth it!), but don’t miss the chance to come by and see him and the other Sicilian treasures on view in the exhibition. Perhaps he’ll whisper his secrets to you. Join us this week on the Getty Voices Facebook and Twitter as we debate the mystery of the Mozia Charioteer, uncover the rich history and culture of Sicily in antiquity and over the succeeding millennia, and go behind the scenes of the exhibition Sicily: Art and Invention between Greece and Rome to discuss conservation and education projects. We'd love to hear your questions and opinions.
Getty Voices: Sicilian Journeys