Your Questions About Alchemy Answered

Meet David and Rhiannon.

David Brafman is the rare books curator at the Getty Research Institute and the curator of The Art of Alchemy, which was on view at the Getty Center through February 12, 2016.

Last week we asked our Instagram followers if they had any questions about alchemy for these two. The questions ranged from “Why was Isaac Newton so darn secretive?” to “What’s the relationship between mirrors and alchemy?” to “What is your favorite alchemical process?” We’re sharing the Q’s and the A’s here. Enjoy! And thank you for your questions.

The Achievements of Alchemists

Is the transformation of one material to another using alchemy actually possible, at least, to an extent? —@Pumpkinlust

Yes. You do this in your kitchen while cooking every day! The preparation of any synthetic material whether for medicine, art, cooking all grows out of alchemy. From earliest antiquity, people could create enough heat to transform sand into glass. This was one of the inspirations for the creation of the field of alchemy. The thing that is actually really hard is changing one element to another. You can do this with a particle collider. David actually wanted to gut the entire interior of the GRI and build a Getty particle collider (it’s the right shape) but it was nixed.—David & Rhiannon

Is there any proof for the creation of a philosopher stone? —@kickflipedro

Depends on what the philosopher's stone is, which people have a lot of different ideas about. It was considered the universal solvent that controlled how all physical matter bonded. We have a manuscript that says the philosopher's stone is red mercury, which is vermillion paint. So if that’s the true philosopher's stone, then yes! The ceramicist Bernard Palissy thought that fossils were the philosopher’s stone, giving creatures true immortality. —David & Rhiannon

What is the relationship of mirrors to alchemy? Neither Gareth Roberts “Mirror of Alchemy” nor Lyndy Abraham's “Dictionary of Alchemical Imagery” are forthcoming on this. —@fr_psnell

Mirrors are one of the many things that alchemists made using their discoveries about the properties of metals and glass. Making glass transparant was developed from Roman to Islamic times. Painting the back of transparent glass with an amalgam of mercury and silver or tin to make the glass reflective may as been developed as early as ar-Razi, but we are still searching for proof.  The earliest testimony we know of about glass mirrors in history is that Pliny the Elder credits Lebanese glassmakers in Sidon as being the first to use transparent glass backed by a molten lead coating. There is a recent novel about alchemical mirror-makers by Martin Seay called “The Mirror Thief.” —David & Rhiannon

What are some legitimate scientific breakthroughs that occurred as a result of alchemists' work? —@Library_de_alexandria

Alchemist is what we used to call “chemist” so all chemical breakthroughs in history before the modern era were done by alchemists. They invented distillation, invented proto-morphine (laudanum), developed oil paints and inks, and also invented new mining techniques. There’s a particularly famous example of an alchemist named Hennig Brand who saved up his pee and distilled it and managed to discover the element Phosphorus. —Rhiannon & David

Alchemy’s Relationship to Other Fields of Study

Is it true that alchemy and the tarot began in ancient Egypt? —@Spacebunny3

Alchemy as we know the word, began in Ancient Egypt after Alexander the Great conquers Egypt we find references to the practice of “chemeia,” Greek word for “metal-pouring” ie alloying of metals. The Egyptians own word for Egypt was “kem” which literally mean black and referred to the mineral rich silts that built up on the banks of the Nile.

Tarot originated in Renaissance Europe as a card game and much of its arcane and esoteric symbolism was derived from the same artistic iconography used to symbolize alchemical ideas. Tarot wasn’t even used for divination until the 18th century. —David & Rhiannon

Do you see any parallels between alchemy and religion then and science and religion nowadays? —@Sassmasteralex

The idea that science and religion are opposite to each other is a relatively modern one. At the turn of the 20th century, scientists were still trying to calculate the weight of the soul. Pope Francis studied chemistry in college. :) Our favorite alchemy tagline, which we sadly had to leave out of our exhibition intro, is “Alchemy was a science tinged with spirituality and infused with a spritz of artistic spirit.” —David & Rhiannon

Was Alchemy ever associated with witchcraft? Did any practicing Alchemists ever get accused of being witches/wizards? —@melissa_tatiana

Alchemists might get in trouble for fraud or counterfeiting money, but witchcraft is specifically dealing with pacts with the devil. These two don’t have too much overlap. —Rhiannon & David

Alchemy is "a seemingly magical process of transformation, creation, or combination." Is chemistry alchemy without the belief in magic? Or better yet, do you think science trie to make magic real and explainable? —@Bookfutureslookbullish

One of Arthur C. Clark’s laws of scifi is “any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.” It’s magical because it inspires wonder, not necessarily supernatural. Also early modern natural philosophers called what they did “natural magic.” Look up “Pharaoh’s Snake” on YouTube. :) —David & Rhiannon

Is alchemy a spiritual or a physical pursuit? Was it understood as magical simply because of the power of physical transformation? —@Aurumrushventure

Both! It’s a spiritual pursuit grounded in a physical one. Our favorite alchemy tagline, which we sadly had to leave out of our exhibition intro, is “Alchemy was a science tinged with spirituality and infused with a spritz of artistic spirit.” —David & Rhiannon

The Song of Solomon is a recurring theme in alchemical texts, especially the Aurora Consurgens. How did the tie between the two evolve? —@Testarossasmom

The Song of Solomon has invited numerous interpretations over the centuries to explain its place in the Bible as a pretty sexy love poem; at the same time, metaphors of sex and reproduction are often used in alchemy to express ideas about chemical bonding, called ‘conjunction’ or ‘coitus.’ Solomon was also famous for his wisdom, making his connection to alchemy an easy one. Alchemists used imagery and references to many different religious traditions, not just Christianity and Judaism but also Islam and the mythology of antiquity. —Rhiannon & David

Who Were the Alchemists?

Who were alchemists?  Did they tend to come from the elites or any class?  Was practicing alchemy an actual profession or more of a hobby? —@Amelialikespie

Alchemists came from all levels of society. Some were educated physicians and pharmacists. Some were working class artisans making synthetic products for sale. Becoming skilled at alchemy was a way to rise in status and gain the favor of nobles. But if got caught faking it, off with your head! One in fact, Michael Maier (not to be confused with the one with hockey mask) becomes the personal physician and closest political advisor to the Holy Roman Emperor, Rudolf II. —David & Rhiannon

Why we did some alchemists, like Isaac Newton, operate under much secrecy or silence? —@Daemonsdiscuss

Isaac Newton, in general, was very secretive because he hated criticism. He published about calculus over 30 years after he invented it because he was nervous about what people would say. He did have shelves of alchemy books in grad school. In general, alchemy was secretive, comparable to how Coca Cola would never share the recipe for coke. —David & Rhiannon

Were there any women alchemists? Feminist alchemists? —@Meowius

Yup! The earliest Egyptian Alchemist we know about was Maria Judaea. Her writings are lost, but her colleagues credit her as many of the earliest alchemical apparatuses. The “Bain-Marie” (a kind of double boiler used to make desserts) was named after her. There were also women alchemists for basically all of history. Lady Geng was a favorite of a Chinese Emperor of the Tang Dynasty. A famous Renaissance book of alchemical secrets is attributed to a Venetian woman, Isabella Cortese. Miranda Kay wrote a book called “Daughters of Alchemy” (2015) about some of these women alchemists.  Many of the alchemy rare books in our collection were owned by women who were using them in laboratory experimentation. —David & Rhiannon

Is Paulo Coelho a real Alchemist? —@chattahoocheeotter

No :)  Please send him our apologies. —David & Rhiannon

How much do we actually know about the historical Nicolas Flamel? —@bilociraptor

All the things about him being an alchemist date from the 17th century and probably a later invention. But you can go visit his house in Paris! —David & Rhiannon

Were many, if any, of the artists, alchemists in their own right? —@Daemonsdomain

Practicing alchemy does not an alchemist make. Not everybody who made a synthetic paint pigment or engaged in metallurgy considered themselves an alchemist. But at the same time, the Renaissance art historian/biographer Vasari does say that some artists were obsessed with alchemy, including Van Eyck and Parmigianino. Vasari says that Parmigianino was one of the most brilliant artists he ever saw, but ruined his career staying up all night playing with chemicals in his lab. —David & Rhiannon

To what extent did Mary Sidney practice alchemy? She is said to have had her own lab and lab assistant, but what is known about what she practiced and/or achieved? —@Apocalipstixnow

Although she’s not really in our show, she was definitely an alchemist. We have some of her recipes that she developed including one for invisible ink. —Rhiannon & David

One of the main centers of Alchemy was Ptolemaic Alexandria, my question is, how advanced do you think they were in their practice? And are there any extant manuscripts which are directly attributable to works from the library of Alexandria? —@Mrjuliantyler

We don’t know of any manuscripts from the Library of Alexandria, but there are papyrus fragments with alchemical recipes from the Nile Delta region of Egypt. —David & Rhiannon