Art, Prints and Drawings

Leonardo da Vinci, Renaissance Lefty

Look closely at a drawing by Leonardo da Vinci and you’ll find telltale signs of his left-handedness

Caricature of a Man with Bushy Hair / Leonardo da Vinci

Caricature of a Man with Bushy Hair, about 1494, Leonardo da Vinci. Pen and brown ink, 2 5/8 x 2 1/8 in. The J. Paul Getty Museum, 84.GA.647

Leonardo da Vinci was an anatomist, architect, botanist, engineer, mathematician, painter, scientist, sculptor, and theoretician. And mancino…Italian slang for “lefty.” While the historical biases and slurs against left-handers—sinister, gauche, and so on—run through my mind, I confess that what I first think of when it comes to left-handedness is Ned Flanders’s Leftorium on The Simpsons.

Leonardo was one of the greatest draftsmen in history, and his handedness left a little-known trace in his drawings: the slope of his lines.

How does the angle of a line indicate whether an artist is left- or right-handed? Well, imagine that you’re asked to shade in a square on a sheet of paper with hatching, or closely set parallel lines. If you’re right-handed, you’ll probably draw strokes from the top right of the sheet to the lower left. If you’re left-handed, you’ll probably sketch lines from top left to lower right. The hatched parallel lines Leonardo used to shade and render his designs slope precisely this way.

The result can be seen in one of the smallest drawings in the Getty Museum’s collection (shown above), which is also one of the best known. It’s about half the size of an iPhone, but is an unforgettable image.

Leonardo generally grouped a number of such “physiognomic expressions,” portraying extremes of expression and facial features, on a single sheet of paper. The Getty example above was likely cut at an early date from a larger sheet; we don’t know when.

From the weight of the ink, we can see how the parallel lines that give shadow to the crazy hair were begun at the bottom and traveled upwards, tapering at the ends. Others surrounding the chin were started on the profile and drawn downwards, as shown by the hook returns at the bottom. But they all slant in the same direction.

Detail of a Caricature of a Man with Bushy Hair / Leonardo da Vinci

Caricature of a Man with Bushy Hair (detail), about 1494, Leonardo da Vinci. Pen and brown ink, 2 5/8 x 2 1/8 in. The J. Paul Getty Museum, 84.GA.647

Leonardo’s left-handedness has come to be regarded as something of a signature, but he was not, of course, the only left-handed artist in the Renaissance. Indeed, according to contemporary sources Michelangelo was innately left-handed but retrained himself to write and draw right-handed, the fate of many lefties of history.

Three Caricature Heads with Grotesque Features / unknown artist after Leonardo da Vinci

Three Caricature Heads with Grotesque Features, 1467–1519, unknown artist after Leonardo da Vinci. Pen and brown ink, 18.5 x 13.3 cm. Image © Trustees of the British Museum

Leonardo’s physiognomic drawings were reasonably well known even during his own lifetime. After he died in France in 1519, they were bequeathed to his pupil Francesco Melzi, who took them back to Milan. Melzi made them available to other artists to study, many of whom, even though they were right-handed, copied the drawings with left-handed hatching to reproduce the original look. To do this they likely turned their own sheets of paper as they drew, but some of the copies were more successful than others.

This drawing in the British Museum includes copies of three of Leonardo’s sketches and quite effectively renders his technique, with long strokes and repeated hook returns.

A drawing in the Metropolitan Museum, which studies only one of Leonardo’s physiognomic heads, is much less successful, resulting in what esteemed Renaissance scholar Carmen Bambach charmingly described as a “salad of short lines.” (If you’re interested in the subject of Leonardo and left-handedness do read her essay on the subject in the comprehensive 2003 catalogue Leonardo da Vinci: Master Draftsman, pages 31 to 57).

The Head of a Grotesque Man in Profile Facing Right / unknown artist after Leonardo da Vinci

The Head of a Grotesque Man in Profile Facing Right, after 1500, unknown artist after Leonardo da Vinci. Pen and brown ink, 3 5/8 x 2 1/8 in. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Rogers Fund, 1917. 17.142.3.

Most of these copies were made by young artists simply learning to draw—it was common to practice by copying the masters. But some of them were no doubt intended to be passed off as original drawings by Leonardo, a practice that has continued through the ages. A forgery in the British Museum’s collection, for example, dates from the early 1900s.

Leonardo da Vinci’s left-handedness is one of the wonderfully distinctive aspects of his draftsmanship, but it is not always prominent. After about 1500 he began to seek more tonal effects that rendered his hatched lines less obvious. With careful observation, however, the left-handedness is almost always apparent. It is a sad fact that during my ten-plus years at the Getty we have more than once been offered drawings for sale that were claimed to be by Leonardo, but were clearly the product of right-handed artists.

To see close-ups of right-handed parallel hatching, have a look at the short slideshow for the exhibition Hatched! Creating Form with Line.

Tagged , , , , Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • Tumblr

    • Polo and Fishing Fore-Edge Painting


      These idyllic fore-edge paintings come from Mary Grey Lundie Duncan’s book entitled Memoir of Mrs. Mary Lundie Duncan: Being Recollection of a Daughter by Her Mother, third edition, published in 1846. After her daughter’s untimely death at 25, Mary Grey Lundie Duncan recorded her daughter’s life and her hymns. Mary Lundie Duncan wrote hymns for her children, most notably “Jesus, tender Shepherd, hear me” and “My Saviour, be Thou near me.”

      As with an earlier post that focused on fore-edge paintings, the art added to books by owners do not always match the subject matter. It’s unclear when the art was added, but polo and fly fishing do not seem to have much of a relationship to the young life of a devout Scottish woman.

      There is more to this book. It was donated to the library by Mr. and Mrs. Herman Brown in memory of their friend Florence Rice “Floy” Rodman Barnhardt. She was born in Minnesota and died in Houston, TX. Her husband, Gen. George Columbus Barnhardt, commanded the 28th Infantry Division in World War I. She and her husband are buried in United States Military Academy Post Cemetery at West Point. The relationship between Floy Rodman Barnhardt and the Browns is unknown, but it must have been close.

      Thanks to our new archival assistant, Alicia Fan, for making the gifs.

      Sources consulted: Mary Lundie Duncan hymns, Minister Henry Duncan, Find a Grave: Florence Rice “Floy” Rodman Barnhardt, and Find a Grave: Gen. George Columbus Barnhardt.

      Fore-edge paintings are fore-ever awesome.


  • Flickr